Wednesday, September 19, 2007

Irrational Crude Oil

September 18, 2007

The crude oil market is once again acting irrationally. Goldman Sachs came out with a piece saying crude could hit the $85 to $100 per barrel point very soon. That alone is usually cause for us to take the opposite side and short this market.

Aat the end of July, I started writing about crude hitting new highs for no apparent reason. We said buy the 70 put options, and if you did you made a very nice return. We're watching for a set up to repeat this trade.

On Wednesday, Sept. 19 the API/Energy Stocks inventory report comes out at 10:30 am EST. There is a good chance the report will show a larger than expected draw down on crude supplies, mostly due to the Huston Ship Channel shutting down for Humberto last week. This could cause a one or two day spike in prices, followed by another sharp move down.

A 50% move down from today's high ($81.11) to August's low would place the Nov. crude oil contract in the $75 range. A Nov. put option with a $75 strike closed today at .83, or $830. If crude oil falls back to this price range within one or two weeks that option would be worth over $2,000 - a pretty nice return for a quick, short-term trade.

We are bearish on crude for these reasons: world inventories are high; the Middle East is relatively calm (Ramadan just started); there have been few storms to disrupt the Gulf shipping lanes and finally, we're winding down out of the gas-guzzling months.

What could mess up this trade: interest rates falling could give traders a reason to think we're suddenly going to start using a lot more oil since the economy will pick up the pace; a big hurricane hitting the Gulf or slowing imports from Mexico; Mid-East troubles and finally, hedge funds continuing to bid up the contract.

Irregardless, we want to buy our puts in the .70 to .80 range, looking for a first goal of of the market hitting $75, then $70. This should give us a two-times investment return on the first leg and a three-to-four times return if Nov. crude can get back to $70.

We are still bullish on natural gas and heating oil. Nat. Gas is a good seasonal play this time of year thanks to Gulf storms, and heating oil is expected to be in shorter supply this year, as we said in the "Battle for Acreage" post on Sept. 11.

If you have any questions or comments please send me a note at davidbrown@midwestfutures.com.

Futures and options trading is speculative and involves a high degree of risk. The risk of loss can be substantial. Neither the information presented or any of the opinions expressed constitute a solicitation for the purchase or sale of any commodities.

No comments: